About Us

Located at the corner of Cedar and Main in downtown Lititz, McElroy Pharmacy is a corner drugstore that combines old-fashioned customer service with the latest advances in technology to give customers rapid and accurate filling of their prescriptions, along with a shopping experience where our staff members get to know you and greet you by name.

An integral part of America's Coolest Small Town, McElroy Pharmacy stands just down the street from America's oldest pretzel bakery (Sturgis) and the oldest private girls school (Linden Hall) in the United States. Being part of this wonderful community is a privilege, and we strive to make a great place even better by supporting many local organizations, including service clubs, schools, and churches.

McElroy Pharmacy's roots run deep in our community. Our name comes from founder Glenn H. McElroy. We have only one store, and we've been at the same location since 1935. Owner Jeff Eshelman, a graduate of Warwick High School, has been a part of the team since 1975, when he started working here as a pharmacist. In 1991, he purchased the business, and he's still filling prescriptions, running the business, and serving his community.

The McElroy Pharmacists

In addition to serving our clients, our pharmacists are active in the community, so you may see them wherever you go.

Adrienne Stauffer, Pharmacist

Adrienne Stauffer, Pharmacist

Adrienne attended West Virginia University, home of the Mountaineers, to complete her undergraduate work. She then in Morgantown to attend the WVU School of Pharmacy and graduated with her Doctor of Pharmacy degree in 2012. Adrienne completed her internship training in community pharmacy, as well as hospital pharmacy. She has worked for Jeff at McElroy Pharmacy for more than 3 years. "I am blessed to be part of the McElroy family and enjoy serving our patients in the Lititz area and beyond."

Danielle Williamson, Pharmacist

Danielle Williamson, Pharmacist

Danielle grew up in western Pennsylvania and graduated from Blacklick Valley Jr./Sr. High School in Nanty Glo in 1992. She earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Pharmacy from the University of Pittsburgh in 1997 and then practiced in a retail setting, gaining 14 years of experience. Four young daughters prompted a brief hiatus, and Danielle has joined the McElroy Pharmacy family. Danielle especially enjoys the personal atmosphere and the small town friendliness that McElroy Pharmacy offers. "I love working and serving in the community where I live and am raising my children."

Jeff Eshelman, Pharmacist/Owner

Jeff Eshelman, Pharmacist/Owner

Jeff is a native of Lititz, and he graduated from Warwick High School and the University of Pittsburgh School of Pharmacy. He has been employed at McElroy Pharmacy since his graduation from Pitt in 1975, and he purchased the business in April 1991 along with his wife Brenda, who serves as the bookkeeper for the business. They have 3 daughters (Warwick High School graduates) and currently 3 grandchildren. Jeff and Brenda are active members of the Lititz Church of the Brethren. "Brenda and I have been blessed to live and work in the Lititz/Warwick School District our entire lives. We have a strong dedication to our community and have enjoyed serving our neighbors and friends throughout the past 40 years."

Tim Rohrer, Pharmacist

Tim Rohrer, Pharmacist

Tim graduated from Manheim Central High School, class of 1998, and the University of Pittsburgh School of Pharmacy, class of 2004. As a Doctor of Pharmacy, he chose to settle in America's Coolest Small Town and to join the McElroy Pharmacy team. Working at a small family-owned pharmacy has fulfilled Tim in many ways. Getting to know patients through years of service and gaining their trust and friendship has been most rewarding. Outside of the pharmacy, Tim enjoys spending time with his wife, Alexis and sons, Benjamin and Noah. His hobbies include biking, grilling and going to the beach with his family.